Barley, Corn, Hops Pricing and Weyerbacher

25 July 2008

With all the talk of increasing beer prices over the last 10 months, I continually hear complaints of high prices, especially complaints focused toward Weyerbacher. I certainly disagee and would take the stance that Weyerbacher produces a high quality beer at a fair price. Over the last few weeks in Happy Hour conversations, I've promised to publish Dan Weirback's Appeal letter...so here it is:

A Treatise and an Appeal or How I Stopped Worrying and Learned to Love Craft Brew, At Any Price

OK, here it is, your inside the industry explanation of the ridiculus price increases in Craft Brew that you are going to see very soon. I’ll explain what’s happened to the price of Malt and Hops and why, what can be done about it, and why you are going to see prices jump likely between 15 and 25% on the retail end for Craft brews in a matter of weeks. I’ll then finish with an appeal to all craft brew fans for continued support. We need it now more than ever to get through this rough period and not lose any more quality craft breweries, which could likely happen to some you might not expect.I own and operate Weyerbacher Brewing Co. (with partners) in Easton, PA, so you’re getting info straight from the brewery. In late September I was told by another brewery that malt was going up about 40% and hops 30 to 40%. I started calling suppliers and they confirmed this was true, and also that they have no prices locked in yet. Additionally, I was informed that many farmers are not honoring their contracts to the fullest extent (don’t blame the farmers please) due to the crazy price situation that’s evolving in crop farming, with corn being twice the price it was last year. What does corn have to do with it? Our supplier tells us that with Uncle Sam’s push for and financial support for ethanol the price for corn has doubled and many farmers grew corn instead of barley this year. In the UK, where the EU has also required ethanol production, rape seed is the crop of choice and again, a lot more profitable than growing barley and wheat. Couple this with bad weather and growing conditions this year and in Europe and you have a crisis in barley supply. We were told this was coming in early summer, but we assumed our malt company might have meant a 10 to 15% increase in price, not this. When we finally got nailed down pricing last week, one malt price was up 45% and the other up 56%. Plus, we were told to be happy that we’re able to get the supply (with growth) that we’ve asked for. Some brewers will not be so luckyNow for Hops. A glut of hops on the market in the mid-90s, caused a 10 year decline in hops acreage and hops farmers throughout the world. Each year more acreage dwindled and it didn’t matter as there was still an oversupply of hops. Beginning perhaps 2 to 4 years ago, the astounding success and strength of the craft brew industry put a big dent in the overage, but prices stayed essentially the same and farmers didn’t have incentive to plant more. Throw in the runaway success of Double IPAs (and bigger) and we’ve jumped up the demand again for those fragrant cones. Sooner or later something had to give. And its happened last month. Rather than going up 30 or 40% as expected, US and European hops have gone up 400%!! That’s not a typo, 400%. There is not enough to go around. Weyerbacher has our supply lined up, but some recipes may require a few substitutions in hops due to lack of supply of some varieties. In a recent Wall Street Journal article on this problem, Larry Bell of Kalamazoo brewing and Jim Koch of Sam Adams were also quoted as saying they would probably have to alter a few recipes.There simply is no choice for some breweries.Some Craft breweries have locked in contracts for several years for supply, but they’re still going to see the price increase sooner or later. Many farmers are not honoring contracts.So where does this bring us? These price increases for Malt and Hops alone amount to a minimum price increase from Weyerbacher to wholesaler of 12 to 14% and it gets worse on the beers that use a lot of hops. Many of our beers will increase about $2.50 per case. Our ingredient cost for Hops Infusion IPA has risen $3.94, so we will raise the price $4.00 per case. Its typical for a business to markup a certained fixed amount from cost, so typically this $4.00 would result in a higher markup to keep our margins this same, but you can see why we can’t do that. When you reach for that 4 pack of Double Simcoe IPA in the New Year, don’t be surprised if its $2.00 to $2.50 higher. Our ingredient cost on this hop bomb went up $8.14 per case. You can see where this is going. Many BIG beers not heavy on the hops will go up perhaps 3 or 4 dollars due to the malt increase.It gets better. A price increase at the brewery of 10 to 15%, just to cover costs, no gouging whatsoever, will result in a price increase at retail of 20 to 25%.So that’s it in a nutshell. The Associated Press and The Wall Street Journal have both written separate articles on this subject in the past 3 weeks.While not officially speaking for the industry, I hope other breweries will join Weyerbacher in an appeal to beer geeks everywhere for their continued support of our industry. We need you now more than ever if we are to continue making great beer. When hops are short and the big 3 industrial brewers will pay anything (almost) to get their hands on them, we need you the consumer to come to a full understanding of what’s going on in our industry. Many craft breweries just get by, with employees typically working 50 to 60 hour weeks, most of whom would not feel they are overpaid. Fuel goes up, glass goes up, cardboard goes up every year, and somehow we have to deal with it. We’ll be OK here, but some breweries may not. We simply ask for your understanding about why the prices have gone up. Thanks for your fantastic support in the past and your (hopefully) continued support in the future.

Cheers!
Dan Weirback, President
Weyerbacher Brewing Co., Inc

2 comments (click to read or post):

blindingblizzard,  25 July, 2008 17:11  

Let's do a sanity check here. I've purchased beer from the brewery at Stoudt's about two months ago, at Victory within the last month, and at Weyerbacher this past Saturday. Victory's prices haven't risen more than a few dollars (~$35 for a mixed case of Pils, HopDevil, Golden Monkey and Storm King - average ABV of 7.5%), Stoudt's about five dollars ($40 for a case a similar ABV brews). I just paid $56 for a mixed case of Weyerbacher beer with an average ABV of 9.5%. Some quick math: 9.5/7.5 = 1.25 x $37.50 = $47. $56/47 = 1.20. Weyerbacher is charging 20% more on average than other local breweries for an equivalent amount of alcohol. I really can't believe Victory and Stoudt's are taking a loss on their beer. The bottom line is that Weyerbacher's prices are ~$10 more per case than the other local breweries (including Troegs, $39 case of Nugget Nectar - sweet). Where's the justification for that? I'll be buying less Weyerbacher beer with so many other quality choices. When I need a Double Simcoe or Insanity fix I'll cave, but otherwise I'll be putting that extra $10 to a few draft beers or an extra six-pack at different establishments.

mybeerbuzz,  25 July, 2008 22:18  

I'm always a little frightened when mixing beer & math, however I think at least for me it breaks down to value. Because of the quality ingredients that go into a beer like double simcoe, for me I'll pay extra. I can say I believe Dan when he says he's not taking home any more money than he was prior to the barley/hops increase. I don't know personally what contracts Dan had in place compared to a larger brewer like Victory. I'd suspect because of their volume, Victory is paying less, again assuming what contracts they had in place. I'll also be the first to say Simcoe hops are not cheap. It's a proprietary rhizome, tree form, and NOT disease resistant...not cheap and not widely available. I'd agree with your point, but comparing breweries of different sizes and not knowing when they negociated their barley & hops contracts is like comparing apples and oranges. Personally I'll buy what I like from Stoudts, Victory and Weyerbacher if I still think it is worth the price....and I DO still think it is worth the price. I spoke at length with teh former owners of Lion about grain & hop contracts, added costs for distribution and everything else that goes into the beer price equation...and believe me, the breweries took a hit. I guess I tend to believe Dan and I'm still willing to pay more. I will however agree that Nugget Nectar, Hopback and a few others are a tremendous value, but I'll happily pay more for Double Simcoe, Imperial Pumpkin Ale, Insanity and a few others coming out of Weyerbacher.

Post a Comment

Please leave a comment...I do moderate them so it may not immediately appear...and please be nice!

Lets Talk Beer!

We've added some tools to encourage interaction. First and foremost, you'll see the Recent Comments section up above. This list displays the most recent comments from individual posts. Feel free to comment on ANY post by clicking on the "comments" link at the bottom of any post, or any link in the Recent Comments section. Comments are moderated, however you can choose to post anonymously.

Please also remember mybeerbuzz is very active on Facebook & Twitter and we DO support RSS feeds for posts and comments.

My NEW Facebook Fan Page Come LIKE it!

WILK Friday BeerBuzz

Advertising

mybeerbuzz.com is not affiliated with any of the advertisers shown above. We run Ads as a way to help offset the costs to run this FREE blog....BUT if you do happen to click on any of these ads (even if you don't buy), we do eventually get a few pennies....literally.

Sponsor mybeerbuzz.com

Creative Commons License
mybeerbuzz.com by mybeerbuzz.com is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.
Based on a work at mybeerbuzz.com.

  © Copyright 2014 mybeerbuzz.com

Back to TOP